Something Rotten in the Land of No Marcellus

The passing of the new impact fee means a lot of communities, even those outside of the producible Marcellus Shale, will see tremendous payouts. But what about those who are in the Marcellus and unable to develop because of the Delaware River Basin Commission?  Robert Nolan takes an in-depth look at how the numbers add up across the state.

Over 400 years ago, in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Marcellus uttered a similar, famous quote with reference to the state of Denmark (“Something is rotten in Denmark”).  Poor soul, he could not have known how relevant his name and his famous line would be in 21st century Wayne County, PA.

Wayne County, PA

Earlier this week, on October 15, 2012, Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett and other state officials announced the first distribution of “impact fees” paid by natural gas companies for the purpose of exploring Pennsylvania’s abundant Marcellus Shale gas reserves.  And, what an eye opener this revenue ought to be, especially for the residents of Wayne County where Marcellus exploration has been stymied for years due to the inept Delaware River Basin Commission (DRBC) whose inexcusable moratorium prohibiting the harvest of these reserves has left Wayne County residents out in the cold, financially deprived and unceremoniously robbed of their property rights.  Let’s call this what it is: Wayne County got hosed and continues to today.

Neighboring counties where gas drilling is permitted, specifically Susquehanna, Bradford and Sullivan and their municipalities, will reap approximately $32,000,000 (thirty two million dollars) from the “impact fees” in the first year alone.  What’s Wayne County’s windfall?  How about $44,814.22! That’s right, less than forty five thousand dollars, and by many accounts, Wayne County could be on top of some of the deepest, richest dry gas reserves in the Marcellus.

But, how about this for another slap in the face for Wayne County?  In the southeast corner of the Commonwealth, the City of Philadelphia will receive $1,294,664.55; Bucks County $530,461.69; Delaware County $474,238.17; Montgomery County $678,613.66.

How many gas wells are there or will there be in Philly and those three counties?  What’s the extent of their shale gas reserves?  The answer is…ZERO.

Yet, they have no shortage of antipathy toward the hand that feeds them.  They are the homes of so many self-serving anti-natural gas activists who have the means and the time to travel a significant distance to deprive others of their property rights and the ensuing bounty they themselves reap.  Attend any Marcellus Shale public meeting or DRBC hearing in our region and you’ll find busloads of them there to protest local landowners developing their own natural resources.  They’ll taunt, spread misinformation, attempt to gin up hysteria, fear-monger, call us greedy hicks, wave $20 bills in our faces and tell us how they’ve come on their white horse to save us ignorant Wayne County residents from the errors of our ways.

Protest outside the Pennsylvania Convention Center in Philadelphia . (AP Photo / Mark Stehle)

Ironic, don’t you think, that these three counties and Philadelphia will receive a total of $2,977,978.07 in “impact fees” or 66.45 times the revenue Wayne County will receive despite being the hotbed of anti-gas activity?  Do you think they and their local politicians, many who are vehemently anti-gas themselves, will take the high road and refuse those checks from the Commonwealth?  Not on your life. There ought to be a law!  Meanwhile, Wayne County did not receive enough revenue to hire a single police officer or a single teacher.

Further exacerbating this have/have not dichotomy is the standard of living in these three suburban Philadelphia counties versus Wayne County. From the latest US Census data 2006-2010 dollars:

So the anti-natural gas crowd travels far and wide from their typically well heeled, suburban prosperity to deny economically deprived Wayne County any hope of prosperity from the ground beneath their feet. When the “antis” don’t venture to Wayne County, there’s a substantial cadre of local NIMBY’s to pick up the slack.

These include folks like my neighbor, Bronx born and bred, who squats on a 0.74 acre parcel and proceeds to tell the rest of us what we can or can’t do with our land and resources.  A couple nights past, I saw him in town and he stated it was getting chilly, so he was going home and firing up the gas heater!  He never grasped the irony.

You would think these folks would look at their neighbors owning much more land and subject to exponentially higher property taxes; folks who have been wonderful, thoughtful stewards of this bucolic paradise for generations, a neighbor who may be an aging farmer who’s no longer able to work the land; and be happy they could use their resources to ease their tax burden.  No way.  They don’t care!

You might think those who so often decry the landed for being greedy for signing gas leases would realize the substantial ad valorem revenue from the “impact fees” would also afford significant benefit for them as well.  No way…they can’t comprehend such a win/win proposition!

My challenge is to you Wayne County folks who have been sitting on the sidelines, who have let others fight for your property rights, for your way of life, for the preservation of your natural resources and the bounty they afford you. How much longer will you be silent while a small group gives of their time, sweat equity and limited financial assets for your benefit?  How can you be content or silent while an unelected body, the DRBC, holds you and your property rights hostages?  Will you continue to sit back on the sofa watching the NFL while you’re being robbed blind?

Thomas Jefferson, in 1776, wrote, “We hold these truths to be self-evident…that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.” Almost 75 years later, Frederic Bastiat wrote, ”The mission of the law is not to oppress persons and plunder them of their property, even though the law may be acting in a philanthropic spirit. Its purpose is to protect persons and property… If you exceed this proper limit — if you attempt to make the law religious, fraternal, equalizing, philanthropic, industrial, or artistic — you will then be lost in uncharted territory, in vagueness and uncertainty, in a forced utopia or, even worse, in a multitude of utopias, each striving to seize the law and impose it on you.”

What will history write of you?


  1. Richard C. August says:

    Will Wayne County residents sit back and watch the NFL while others take all their rights, and jobs, and children, away from them?

    Why not? They did so when S. J. Bailey and Sons Furniture moved to Carbondale because of a Keystone Tax-Free Opportunity Zone break, along with constructing a new building there to boot!

    Why not? They did so when Freedlove ladies’ clothing store moved to Adams Ave. in Scranton, a distressed city with a crazy mercantile tax, and shuttered its original store on Main St. in Honesdale, because that store couldn’t get a bug’s worth of foot traffic in the door. That’s because OUR young women are working — and spending their money — in beautiful downtown SCRANTON.

    Why not? They did so when Brian Cobb wisely sold Pocono Mountain Screen Supply on Chapel Street to new owners, who moved the entire COMPANY to Ash Street in Scranton.

    Why not? They did so when Kearfott division of Singer Manufacturing tried to put a warehouse for its helicopter parts for the Defense Department on 4th Street in Honesdale during the Viet Nam era. Local NIMBYs (read: store owners) protested against that because Kearfott offered a starting wage of $13.00 per hour. Now, that whatchamacallit on 4th St. is a condemned, empty shell.

    Why not? They did so during the last Great Recession, when so many of our young adults graduated from local high schools and were forced to join the military to get a job. I know. I was one of them.

    Why not? They did so when a bunch of asinine NIMBYs protested against Flexible Foam Products occupying the former Chroma Tube TV plant in White Mills, even though Wayne Economic Development Corporation jumped through fiery hoops to get that property designated a Keystone Opportunity Zone. Later, those same ass-headed NIMBYs protested against a metal fabrication company occupying the same plant. Now, that plant sits empty. The only real commerce in White Mills is a cactus dealer, an art gallery, and an auto repair shop with a convenience store and deli.

    Why not? They did so when William Manowitz headed HUSSCO Shoe Co., marketing some of the best made shoes in the nation, and boondoggled the money in New York City, turning their shoe plant into a crap store. Now, Wayne Memorial Health Systems owns the property, and even then, they are too big for their britches, being the only “health care” game in town aside from independent doctors. Even so, they have to have “tenure” at the hospital to stay here.

    Why not? They did so when two former local Doctors bought Katz Department Store on Main St. in Honesdale and turned that into “Tiffany’s, volume 2.” Instead of the Katz family owning the store and providing quality goods to local residents, that entire building is made up of university branch locations, small shops, and offices. Once more, downtown Honesdale is doomed.

    Why not? They did so when the Honesdale Christian Book Store underwent changes to become “The Salt Shaker,” “The Salt Shaker/Book Nook,” and lastly “Footprints,” only to close its doors after 40 years of good service to our town. Local businesses neither have enough jobs nor enough respect to hire the ladies who worked there the longest just to keep them in Dutch, and one of these ladies drives daily to Kingston to her job. OK, so the storefront is now filled by “The Gentle Arts,” which is a fine store for yarn and remnants, but how long will that last?

    Why not? They did so when The Remnant Shop closed its doors after decades of good service to people who made clothes for themselves and their families.

    Why not? They did so when Shoe Fair closed its doors on the south end of Main Street, and its former owner wound up being a financial advisor in SCRANTON.

    Why not? They did so when so many youth of all religious backgrounds left the area in droves that the only Jewish Temple in all of Wayne County now is only open during the High Holy Days.

    Sitting and watching NFL is starting to become the only profitable thing in Wayne County, really. Aside from a major hospital billing company setting up in Orson, and more than a few shopping malls in Hamlin, it’s more profitable to sit and collect government benefits than it is to TRY to find a job here.

    As much as I hate gas drilling here, I challenge Wayne County residents to prove me wrong. The NIMBY syndrome here smacks something of the old tale, “The Pied Piper of Hamelin.” With one tune piped on his flute, he drove all the rats out of the town. When he requested payment for his services, the townspeople refused, citing lack of money. He piped another tune, and marched their children off to the same lake in which he drowned all the rats. He therefore drowned their children in an ignominious manner.

    Please, Wayne County residents, I beg you, let industry grow here so people can go to work. If you do not allow regulated, long-term industry to grow here, then your children and grand-children will not grow here, either.


    Richard C. August

  2. Bill Shaughnessy says:

    Well said, and that is coming from a resident of Montgomery County.

  3. Bob Nolan aka SideShowBob says:

    Thanks to my fellow blogger and Dimock resident, Anne Van Lenten, for taking the Scranton Times Tribune to task in her October 18th blog “Dimock Proud Calls Scranton Times Tribune On Their Wordy Rehash” posted immediately following my blog. The Times Tribune coverage of Dimock has been a disgrace. Want further evidence of this inept rag’s coverage of the Marcellus Shale development…???…look no further than the paper’s October 16th edition which is linked in my blog above. One would think $32 million dollars to three rural, economically depressed Northeastern PA counties would merit a significant, positive headline. Not in the Times Tribune. They ran the story on the front page, below the fold under the banner “Fee benefits Bradford, Susquehanna” with the follow up on page A10 under the banner “Impact:Counties, municipalities get cash. One need peruse the article for a scintilla of positives regarding Marcellus Shale development.

    But Dimock…in an attempt to gin up a controversy on September 30 the Times Tribune ran ““The Methane Mess: Are leaking wells still allowing methane to seep into Dimock’s water?” and “Are leaking wells letting methane get into Dimock’s water?”

    The bias of the yellow rag is pathetic….!!!

Speak Your Mind